| Question: | |
| Q. Is the Holy Qur’an complete? | |
| Answer: | |
| A. The Holy Qur’an is complete and without any change either for more or for less. The Shia Ulema (scholars) have written many books confirming this fact. Sayyed Mohammed Musawi |
| Question: | |
| why music is haraam ??, | |
| Answer: | |
| Listening to music which is used by sinners is a sin. If you are in a place where music is played and you can not stop it, and can not leave the place, then you should not pay attention to it, till you can leave the place or stop the music. Every act which is forbidden in Islam (Haraam), is forbidden because it is very harmful, as Allah (SWT) has conveyed to humans through the Prophet (SAWA). We might understand some extend of the harm, or we may do not know , but we remain believing the Allah is The All Knowing, The Most Merciful and The Most Wise,so, we follow what is been conveyed to us to avoid the damage in this life and the punishment hereafter. Wassalam Mohammad al-Musawi http://wabil.info/viewqa.aspx?fi=1868 |
| Question: | |
| I heard a saying of prophet s.a.w that recite namaz in the way you see me. is it correct? | |
| Answer: | |
| Yes it is correct. The Hadeeth saysصلوا كما رأيتموني أصلي (Sallo kama ra'atomooni osalli) which means that we have to pray as the Prophet (SAWA) prayed. The Prophet never folded his hands while praying, and never washed his feet in Wudhu and never said Ameen after reciting Al Hamd in Salaat,etc You must follow the prayer of the Prophet (SAWA) and as we did not witness him, we must take it from the most authentic source who are his Ahlul Bayt (AS)who prayed just like the Prophet (SAWA) following his teachings. Any narration which goes against what Ahlul Bayt (AS) said is invalid. This is the reason that we say that the Real Prayer is been performed by the folowers of the Prophet (SAWA) and his Ahlul Bayt (AS). Wassalam. Mohammad al-Musawi http://wabil.info/viewqa.aspx?fi=2138 |
| Question: | |
| does abu bkar lead in nmaz in illness of huzoor s.w.a | |
| Answer: | |
| Not at all. This narration is fabricated and we have enough authentic evidences that Abu Bakr was never ordered by the Prophet (SAWA) but was told by his own daughter Aysha to lead the prayers with out the permission of the Prophet Mohammad (SAWA), and when the Prophet (SAWA) knew that Aysha has told her father to go to lead the prayers, the Prophet (SAWA) walked to the Masjid with his pain and illness, supported by Imam Ali (AS) and Al Fadhl Ibn Al Abbas, and dragged back Abu Bakr from the Mihrab and led the Prayer himself. These evidences are in many important Sunni books including Saheeh al Bukhari 1/236 and 1/243. Wassalam. Mohammad al-Musawi http://wabil.info/viewqa.aspx?fi=2616 |
| Question: | |
| when yazid and aale umaiyya are dead, frm whom will imam take revenge after zahoor??? | |
| Answer: | |
| The answer is in Raj'at when Allah (SWT) will bring back to this life the best of His servants and the worst of His enemies. Both will witness the victory of Islam. Wassalam. Mohammad al-Musawi http://wabil.info/viewqa.aspx?fi=4573 |
| Question: | |
| assaamalaikum,is it allowed to eat food prepared by kafir,in taqleed of agha sistani | |
| Answer: | |
| Assalamu alaikum wr wb It is not allowed to eat any Najis food whether it was prepared by a Muslim or non Muslim. Sometimes food is prepared by non Muslim using gloves with out touching the food directly, in such case the food is not Najis if it does not contain any Najis item like non Halal meat. Food prepared by Christian or Jew is allowed according to Ayatullah seestani if it does not contain non Halal meat ingrediant or alcohol or any Najis item. Wassalam Mohammad al-Musawi http://wabil.info/viewqa.aspx?fi=1041 |
| Question: | |
| Q.Is It obligatory to do taqleed of a Gair Masoom A Person who Is not from 14 masoomeen if it is then please showprove from quran or hadees. | |
| Answer: | |
| Taqleed is acting upon the verdict of the Mujtahid (highly learned in Islamic knowledge). Taqleed is obligatory on the rules of Shariah on every one who is unable to deduct the evidences of Islamic rules. He must them do Taqleed to make his deeds based on the evidences of a highly learned (Mujtahid). Following the Masoom is must and it is not Taqleed but following the teachings of Allah which come from the Masoom. When we do not have a clear teaching from the Masoom in any matter, we need then to make a research (for those who can do so) or do Taqleed of a Mujtahid. assalam Mohammad al-Musawi http://wabil.info/viewqa.aspx?fi=1307 |
| Question: | |
| Was Prophet Muhammad PBUHHP assasinated or did he die a natural death? Please provide me with both Shia and sunni references. | |
| Answer: | |
| It is mentioned in both Sunni and Shia books that the Prophet Mohammad (SAWA) was poisoned, as you can see in Saheeh al Bukhari(Hadeeth 4165, 2617, 4428 and 5777) and Saheeh Muslim (Hadeeth 2190), and Musnad Ahmad Bin Hanbal, 2/451, and Sunan Abi Dawood (Hadeeth 4508), and Sunan al Daarimi 1/32, and Al Mustadrak by al Haakim 3/19 and 3/209. In Shia books you can see Bihaarul Anwaar 6/21 and 27/217 and many other books, Although there is an agreement between Sunni and Shia scholars that the Prophet was poisoned, but there is a difference on the origin of the poison, as many Sunni books narrate that it was by a Jewish woman from the time of Khaybar which was long before the death of the Prophet (SAWA), while you see in Sunni books that the Prophet was forcibly given a drink when he was unconscious during his heavy illness against his wish and against his clear orders, and when he came to know about it, he told them : Did I not tell you not to give me that drink? and he ordered to give the same to all who were present except his uncle. Saheeh al Bukhari (Hadeeths 4458, 5712, 6886, and 6897) and Saheeh Muslim (Hadeeth 2213) and Musnad Ahmad Bin Hanbal 6/53,118. http://wabil.info/viewqa.aspx?fi=2171 |
© 2013 SHIA - Q&A. All rights resevered. Designed by Templateism
